Transgene

The history of pig genome research enters the matrix

In the TRANSGENE project we are committed to using approaches from different disciplines to make sense of the historical material, and to generate new data from which to form a picture of the genomic research. One of the key approaches is the use of quantitative methods, imported from the social sciences. Mark Wong from the team is leading on this with his work on bibliometric analysis. I have tried to adopt some of the spirit of that work, if not the rigour and extent, as part of my own work analysing pig genome research. So far, I have been working on two matrices, spreadsheets on which to enter numerical values. One is based on data from the website www.lens.org on co-applications for patents containing the term ‘Sus scrofa’, the scientific name for the pig. For the patent-based matrix, I identified a list of people in the pig community from authorship of particular papers and being named as participants in particular research projects. I then entered into the matrix the number of times they had been listed as a co-applicant with other individuals. The source data is flawed, and the resulting data is therefore far from perfect. However, the object of the exercise was not to achieve a perfect record of everything ever patented to do with the pig, but rather to generate a network map depicting the connections between people, and the strength of those connections. Mark ran the matrix through a neat programme called UCINET. I had certain expectations about what the network might look like. I was surprised when it did not match those expectations in a number of areas. Two key surprises are the positions and connections of Graham Plastow and Martien Groenen. Plastow had worked in industry with the Pig Improvement Company (PIC). While at PIC he interacted a great deal with pig genome researchers and so his name comes up in interviews. He was not, however, a co-author of key papers, or a member of certain projects. In this network map, however, he is revealed as a central figure. He is a co-applicant for patents with many other people, who in turn are co-applicants with other people. This shows the power of different kinds of data in revealing connections and collaborations. Collaboration sometimes leaves no tangible trace, or traces that are only revealed by examining different kinds of data. Martien Groenen has been at the heart of pig genome research in Europe and the world. Yet in the patent co-applicant map, he is in a small, separate network. It would be absurd to conclude from this that Groenen was a marginal, poorly-connected figure. So what value is the network map? Its value lies in the reflections that it provokes through a mismatch between expectations and the depiction of the network. It therefore only has value if one has a prior conception of pig genome research and the actors operating in it. It prompts questions as to why certain figures appear well-connected and others do not, and how the nature of their research, or the type of their institution, or the kinds of collaborations that they participate in, shape the data.

James Lowe, February 2017

The network map produced using UCINET from data on patent co-applicants obtained from www.lens.org using the search term 'Sus scrofa'. Note the sub-networks that I have circled in red; the upper one contains researchers mostly based in Europe, the lower one contains researchers mostly based in North America. Circled in blue are Graham Plastow, a well-connected former Pig Improvement Company employee, and Martien Groenen, who by other measures is also very well-connected and a central figure in pig genome research.

Pig map

Latest Blog Posts

Extracting value from digitizing microbes in Oslo – a ReDig workshop

Nothing about the city centre of Oslo would tell you that you’re in the same country as the sharp-edged fjords that characterise the north of Norway. Nothing directly, that is; indirectly, the city’s excellent public transportation, copious public sculptures, and other amenities speak to the wealth derived from oil and … (Read more)

Past and present of human genomics at the National Institutes of Health

The TRANSGENE project was invited to a workshop organised by the National Human Genome Research Institute of the United States (NHGRI) to explore both historical perspectives and present-day prospects of genomics research. The meeting gathered academic scholars and administrators involved in past and present NHGRI initiatives, such as the Human … (Read more)

Portraits of blue-skies research at Carlsberg Laboratory

Portraits of blue-skies research at Carlsberg Laboratory Claes Gausmann, yeast geneticist at Carlsberg Laboratory in Copenhagen, tells me that the problem with automating yeast research is akin to the problem with automating fly flipping as described by Jenny Bangham in her work on Drosophila stock centers. It should not be … (Read more)

Turning research organisms on their head at 4S in Australia

Rachel Ankeny and Sabina Leonelli have done a great deal to shape and populate history and philosophy of science attention to model organisms through their joint work over the past two decades. At present, that work is continuing to play out in Ankeny's Australian Research Council-funded project “Organisms and Us: … (Read more)

Yeast as a model organism at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory

As I scuffed my shoes on scattered tree branches, bits of broken asphalt, and varied road debris with fast-moving lorries and sports cars whizzing past my right shoulder, it occurred that one of the principle scientific advantages of Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory is isolation. While the laboratory campus is on … (Read more)

Panel on working with large datasets in the history of science - call for expressions of initial interest

Ahead of the formal call for papers for the 2019 British Society for the History of Science conference (which will be held in Edinburgh, 10-13 July), we would like to request expressions of interest in participating in a panel at the conference on the theme of working with large datasets … (Read more)

New publication: 'Sequencing Through Thick and Thin'

The first peer-reviewed publication arising from the TRANSGENE project has now been published online by the journal Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences. Entitled 'Sequencing through thick and thin: Historiographical and philosophical consequences', the paper by James Lowe details a more inclusive conception of DNA sequencing … (Read more)

TRANSGENE on European genomics

At the recent conference of the European Society for the History of Science in London, the TRANSGENE team organised a symposium chaired by Robert Bud on the crucial role of European transnational collaboration in the history of genomics. We argued that the narrative that equates genomics with human genomics, and … (Read more)

TRANSGENE goes to the Fringe

On 22nd August, TRANSGENE took part in the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, the largest arts festival in the world. As part of the ‘Cabaret of Dangerous Ideas’ strand, James Lowe presented a show entitled ‘Will Pigs Save Our Bacon?’ at The Stand’s New Town Theatre on George Street. The Cabaret of … (Read more)

The future of sustainable food production?

On July 18th, I attended a horizon-scanning workshop on food sustainability hosted by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics. The aim of the meeting was to scope out the challenges facing food sustainability over the medium and long-term, and to examine what biological research and innovation is being conducted to try … (Read more)

The Canadian chapter of the history of human genomics

Miguel Garcia-Sancho, PI of the TRANSGENE project and lead investigator of the human genome strand, visited Toronto and Montreal last April to conduct historical research and participate in an interdisciplinary workshop on medical innovation. He visited the archives of the University of Toronto Hospital for Sick Children and conducted oral … (Read more)

Exploring pig genetics in France

At the end of November, I followed in the footsteps of many of the pig geneticists whose work I have been researching, and visited the Jouy-en-Josas campus of the French Institut national de la recherche agronomique (INRA), just south of Paris. At there and other INRA sites in Paris itself, … (Read more)

Advisory Board Meeting and Second Phase of Project

First Advisory Board meeting The TRANSGENE team presented its first findings to an Advisory Board comprised by Stephen Hilgartner (Cornell University), Robert Bud (Science Museum, London), Michel Morange (University Paris 6 and Ecole Normale Superieure), Abigail Woods (King’s College, London) and Hans-Jörg Rheinberger (Max Planck Institute for the History of … (Read more)

The unusual pioneer of the Human Genome Project

When we think about prime-movers, proposing for the first time the idea of scientifically tackling the human genome, the usual suspects come to our mind: reputed biomedical Nobel Prize winners such as James Watson, Walter Gilbert or Renato Dulbecco, who formulated their grand idea in the front pages of Science, … (Read more)

TRANSGENE on tour

…at the British Society for the History of Science conference Amongst the sizeable Edinburgh contingent at the annual British Society for the History of Science conference, this year held in York, were representatives from the TRANSGENE project team. Miguel García-Sancho presented the progress on the yeast strand of the project … (Read more)

June events

The TRANSGENE project operates within the Science, Technology and Innovation Studies (STIS) subject group at the University of Edinburgh. This multidisciplinary affiliation, and association with the Institute for the Study of Science, Technology and Innovation (ISSTI) research network, enables us to discuss our work with researchers that have a wide … (Read more)

Classifying people, practices and institutions

Just as classifications of species, genes, stages of development, or macromolecules can shape research in biology, classification in the humanities and social sciences can condition our analyses. In the pig strand of the project I’m working on, classifying people, practices and institutions is necessary. My aim is to explain, so … (Read more)

The yeast telomeres

Writing the history of the yeast genome project starting from the end, more precisely the chromosome ends, can be an instructive exercise. Chromosome ends (telomeres) are specialised structures essential for chromosome maintenance and genome stability. As yeast telomeres are similar in structure and function to the telomeres of the other … (Read more)

Collaborating with the European Bioinformatics Institute (EMBL-EBI)

In March 2017, I am conducting a three-week visiting post-doctoral fellowship at the European Bioinformatics Institute (EMBL-EBI, Cambridge UK), for the bibliometric and “big data” strand of the project. I am collaborating with the EBI’s Literature Services to advance the project’s aims of mapping institutional networks in genomic sequencing initiatives … (Read more)

The history of pig genome research enters the matrix

In the TRANSGENE project we are committed to using approaches from different disciplines to make sense of the historical material, and to generate new data from which to form a picture of the genomic research. One of the key approaches is the use of quantitative methods, imported from the social … (Read more)

Tracing the history of European biotechnology in the HAEU

My week-long visit to the Historical Archives of the European Union (HAEU) in Florence has proved to be a remarkable opportunity for investigating the ‘behind the scenes’ of European biotechnology policies in the 1980s and 1990s. During my visit in Florence I mainly examined documents available in the Gordon Adam’s … (Read more)

Scientific archives and the history of genomics

In November 2016 Miguel Garcia-Sancho, James Lowe and I attended the Workshop on Scientific Archives organised by Anne Flore-Laloë, archivist at the European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL) in Heidelberg. The meeting brought together tens of archivists from Germany, France, Switzerland, UK, US and Canada. The workshop presentations focused on best … (Read more)